Releasing Control

I think many problems come from trying to control outcomes of what we fear.

Like a lot of things in life, by trying to exert overt control, we end up hurting ourselves more.

I spoke with Emu-Felicitas Ostermann-Miyashita, a social scientist at Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology, about the recovery of wolf populations in Europe, which were locally extinct there for over 100 years in some cases.

This is a jarring shift for generations that lived without wolves. The recovery hasn’t been linear. In just ten years, between 2012 and 2022, Europe's wolf population rose by 58%. Farmers who once lived without worrying about wolves preying on their livestock now have to contend with that reality.

How they chose to do that is where the debate lies. Ostermann-Miyashita studied this interaction in Germany and finds that, generally, a mindset shift is needed: humans should see themselves as part of nature, rather than seeing nature as something to control.

This doesn’t mean there can’t be policy or situations where it’s okay for a human to kill a wolf. But it also doesn’t mean letting humans obliterate wolf populations is a good option. The EU voted to loosen protections on wolves, but environmental organizations have expressed apprehension about the move. Ostermann-Miyashita says this policy was probably driven more by social pressure than by scientific evidence that it’s a good idea.

Holistic approaches to human-wildlife coexistence are not black and white, and I think that makes them harder to pitch to a wide audience, or even a small part of one. No one really wants to hear “the answer isn’t really clear; we need to be careful and study the right approach.” People want solutions now; they want action now.

I think fear drives us to take hasty actions we later regret.

Sometimes the right action is to pause and study what to do. Listen to a wide array of people, try things slowly, and build a network of solutions tailored to each situation. Europe is a large place, and different places will require different approaches. Some solutions may work across many borders; others won’t.

That can be frustrating.

But deliberate work done slowly is better than terrible work done really fast.

Some things in life have a clear answer, and action can be taken swiftly. We love hearing those solutions, and we love seeing them implemented. When we have to study something and adjust as we go, it can be exhausting.

But I think it’s actually the only way in many cases to get where we want to go. Farmers need to make a living. Wolves need to survive and thrive. Both things can occur at the same time, but it takes the patience and persistence of many people to coordinate.

It’s completely achievable.

I had another conversation with an expert working on African lion coexistence in Zimbabwe. I’ll be releasing that one soon. In the meantime, please listen to Emu-Felicitas Ostermann-Miyashita.

Image credit: a Broad-leaved Paperbark (Melaleuca quinquenervia), Sydney. Photo by Mike DiGirolamo.

Next
Next

What Is Discipline For?